Women & Work: The Case of Y.P.F. v. Astra
Part III: ¿De
Dónde Viene?
The Ethnic Variable
in Women's Labor Opportunity
While
for men occupation and location were certainly influenced by their
ethnicity, for women the more important factor in finding paid employment
in the oil industries of Astra and Y.P.F. was the family network. Both
companies inscribed this need for family ties in their stipulations
for some paid female labor: in Y.P.F. and Astra alike, only women
who were daughters of tenured oil workers (minimum of 5 years with the
company) or widows of former workers were eligible to gain employment
in occupations such as office administration. But just as ethnic composition
of the towns affected the work of males in particular networks, certain
patterns arose in women's work according to their ethnicity.
I
n Astra, over 37% of the female work force from 1919-1945 were single
women. Moreover, their nationality was overwhelmingly German:
of the twelve women, there were six German workers, one Austrian, one
Polack, one Czech, and three Argentines.
This preponderance of German workers
and secondary Argentine female laborers was in part due to the respective
population sizes of the two groups. But it was also a result of
differing cultural assumptions about the nature of "women's work."
In general, the German tradition accepted the idea of women's work in
transition from the father's house to the husband's house more so than
either the Argentine or other European nationalities. However, both Argentine
and German women were teachers, many of whom were young and unmarried.
|
Click on image for larger versio
|
|
Ethnicity as a dimension in women's labor played out more
markedly in Y.P.F for different ethnic groups. For example, extra-domestic
work among Italian women during the 1920s and '30s during the company
town was virtually unheard of. The one fairly "appropriate" female
occupation, teaching, was not even approved of by many Italian families,
with Southern Italian immigrants being the least accepting of women's
work outside the home.
|
Click on image for larger version
|
|
Only
under conditions of widowhood could most Italian women freely seek
employment in these decades, which was usually cleaning the public bathrooms
built by Y.P.F. This case was considered an exception, since for most
women the only reason for immigrating to and living in the company towns
was to accompany their husbands, fathers, or other male relatives already
working there. Left without an income and potentially without
company housing, these widows were viewed more sympathetically and as a result
were more accepted by the Italian community as paid workers in Y.P.F. But
overall strict gender roles continued to prevail; although some women
that immigrated to the company from Italy later on in the '40s did work as
clerks, nurses, or teachers, their number was comparatively small.
|
Additionally,
many Spanish and Portugese women in Y.P.F. took their "domestic" skills
such as sewing and mending into the paid labor market. They were
hired as seamstresses and tailors in the workshops, or Talleres,
of the company town starting in the 1920s. Though this allowed
women some autonomy in earning an income separate from their husbands,
it was also confining, in that it was also problematic as "women's work"
because it seemed to be an extension of their housework and role as
mothers.
|